Doctor, doctor
You probably didn�t hear about it. The explanation is very simple. It has nothing to do with the IIMs or the IITs. It is about the fate of the thousands of doctors of this country. The All India Post-graduate Medical Entrance exam was held on January 8, 2006. Over 57,000 students appeared and over 4,000 qualified the exam. The results were announced some where in early February. One of my friends got rank 8! On 1 March, however, we were shell-shocked when we heard that the counseling scheduled for 3 March was postponed and the entrance results were withheld. The honorable health minister Dr.Anbumani Ramadoss woke up suddenly and ordered a CBI enquiry into reported malpractices from Chennai centers. Some 37 of the top 100 ranks were from the same center in Chennai. One might wonder �why did they announce the results in the first place?� The same thing happened in 2002. The organizers should have studied the results before they had released them. But no, they were too busy making policies of such great importance like, um, ban on on-screen smoking. The entrance is one of the toughest. Doctors take off a year to prepare for this exam. One of the reasons is that this exam does not have reservation quota. The other PG entrance exams like AIIMS have quotas. Why should we have reservations at the PG level? God only knows. Will you go to a doctor if you discovered he got his PG seat using the reservation quota? The hell you will. Anyway, we don't know what this means. Will they have a re-exam and tax thousands of hard-working doctors to punish a bunch of losers? Or will they say 'no discrepancies were found' and get on with it? We don't know.
The aspirants are devastated and haven't a clue what turn their life will take next, thanks to our sensitive and intelligent health minister.
What is the big deal did you say? Doctors in our country struggle a lot. They start earning money�whatever little that is� in their late 20s. By that time, their software engineer siblings, cousins, and friends would have bought an apartment, a car, and what not. I know that we can�t compare professions. Don't tell me about Oranges and Apples cowboy.
Why do we screw our doctors? Their profession is life-saving right? Even our movies show doctors as evil, corrupt individuals who have no social responsibility. So, when they go on strike, we dish out harsh punishment. We sack them. When the bus drivers, phone department employees, or the electricity department employees go on strike, we bear with them. In most cases we give in to their demands. But not to doctors. They go on strike, they are fired. What kind of an unfair system is this? One that hurts its most valuable member.
The on-going strike by resident doctors in Maharashtra is a result of years of government apathy. Before we dig deeper let me tell you how resident doctors in government colleges work. They work 18 hours shifts. They have no facilities. Their hostels are so dirty, quite a few of them sleep in the wards. And, they get paid peanuts. Don�t think that the Maharashtra doctors are on a strike because of all that. They merely want security. This time a patient�s daughter slapped a resident. All he did was that he sought permission for some post-mortem related thing. It is ironic that the life saving professional has to go through all this nonsense and be socially responsible too.
How many of these citizens visit only the government hospitals for treatment? Who are they kidding? We can�t even hold a fair entrance examination. We don�t even offer them basic amenities. We let people manhandle doctors. And now, we want them to shut up about their problems too. When they go to America, we call them traitors. We are such losers, it is not even funny. Why do we expect others to be self-righteous when most of us individuals (even the software guys from Bangalore) won�t even follow simple traffic rules? At times, at the risk of causing injury or even death to our fellow motorists? But each one of us gushed and went into a tizzy of manufactured patriotism about that loser movie RDB? Now, if you really want to make a difference start with the traffic rules. Stop honking you retard. And get a real bike. Lose that Pulsar.
So, doc, I am okay if you go to USA or UK, become super-rich, and be happy.
Anyway, one may think that life is easier for Indian doctors in the USA. It was. But not any more. Check this out . In UK, it has become worse:
See http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcfour/documentaries/timeshift/raj-int.shtml and http://www.aippg.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=27399
So there you have it. The Indian doctor is screwed in his/her own country and in the rest of the world too. If we don�t start respecting these life-saving professionals and make some drastic changes in medical education policies, we will be at the receiving end very soon. Think about it. Add to:del.icio.us| Digg| Reddit| StumbleUpon| Technorati
The aspirants are devastated and haven't a clue what turn their life will take next, thanks to our sensitive and intelligent health minister.
What is the big deal did you say? Doctors in our country struggle a lot. They start earning money�whatever little that is� in their late 20s. By that time, their software engineer siblings, cousins, and friends would have bought an apartment, a car, and what not. I know that we can�t compare professions. Don't tell me about Oranges and Apples cowboy.
Why do we screw our doctors? Their profession is life-saving right? Even our movies show doctors as evil, corrupt individuals who have no social responsibility. So, when they go on strike, we dish out harsh punishment. We sack them. When the bus drivers, phone department employees, or the electricity department employees go on strike, we bear with them. In most cases we give in to their demands. But not to doctors. They go on strike, they are fired. What kind of an unfair system is this? One that hurts its most valuable member.
The on-going strike by resident doctors in Maharashtra is a result of years of government apathy. Before we dig deeper let me tell you how resident doctors in government colleges work. They work 18 hours shifts. They have no facilities. Their hostels are so dirty, quite a few of them sleep in the wards. And, they get paid peanuts. Don�t think that the Maharashtra doctors are on a strike because of all that. They merely want security. This time a patient�s daughter slapped a resident. All he did was that he sought permission for some post-mortem related thing. It is ironic that the life saving professional has to go through all this nonsense and be socially responsible too.
A citizen's group has filed a petition against the Maharashtra doctor's strike in the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court. The petition says that doctors in government medical colleges and hospitals have no right to go on strike, and demands compensation for patients who have suffered. [Via NDTV]
How many of these citizens visit only the government hospitals for treatment? Who are they kidding? We can�t even hold a fair entrance examination. We don�t even offer them basic amenities. We let people manhandle doctors. And now, we want them to shut up about their problems too. When they go to America, we call them traitors. We are such losers, it is not even funny. Why do we expect others to be self-righteous when most of us individuals (even the software guys from Bangalore) won�t even follow simple traffic rules? At times, at the risk of causing injury or even death to our fellow motorists? But each one of us gushed and went into a tizzy of manufactured patriotism about that loser movie RDB? Now, if you really want to make a difference start with the traffic rules. Stop honking you retard. And get a real bike. Lose that Pulsar.
So, doc, I am okay if you go to USA or UK, become super-rich, and be happy.
Anyway, one may think that life is easier for Indian doctors in the USA. It was. But not any more. Check this out . In UK, it has become worse:
See http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcfour/documentaries/timeshift/raj-int.shtml and http://www.aippg.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=27399
So there you have it. The Indian doctor is screwed in his/her own country and in the rest of the world too. If we don�t start respecting these life-saving professionals and make some drastic changes in medical education policies, we will be at the receiving end very soon. Think about it. Add to:del.icio.us| Digg| Reddit| StumbleUpon| Technorati
16 Comments:
Dude... You can remember this day as one where you posted a socially not just relevant but critical post and that I concuured with you fully (well almost). Forget the differences. I think you hit the nail so hard on its head in this argument that if the minister were to read this he should be crinjing in shame.
Seriously, if we dont do something to the medical education scenario in India we are all positively screwed (with a big S).
great post
vasu
Tanku tanku.
thank you, suman.
You are right Suman. The doctors in India need better treatment. How I wish the doctors mete out the same good treatment to departed souls (treatment refers to respect in this context). I am sure you know this stinking hospital in Chennai called Malar. Well I can name many but can just think of this one first when it comes to unethical practices. Malar hospitals Mgmt and the doctors working there dont even show some respect for the dead ! They keep the dead for an extra 2-3 days in the pretext of ongoing treatment and charge the dead man's family fees for those 2-3 days too.
Well we can say that probably these guys are so psyched with the treatment meted out to them in their residence days that they mete out the same INHUMAN behaviour to people. Please note that I am not accusing all doctors, I am talking about some of them...but please dont generalise that we screw our doctors, doctors screw us and the dead too !!!
Suman, so true about the state of the S Asian doctors in the UK, it is really pathetic and something needs to be done about it urgently. Some of them are living in pitiable conditions in East London, it is so sad.
Docs in London? Don't even talk about them...who asked them to go all the way to earn a living there? Would a few bucks less hurt if they could serve in the country with some dignity?
he has in effect killed my sister. I certainly did not like the words used by him. Quote: �Don�t tell me how to run my unit, I will run it as I please!� And this was in Apollo Hospital,Chennai.
Read the complete post " My sister �Sowmya� " on this blog
http://wonderfulthoughts.blogspot.com/2006/03/my-sister-sowmya.html
Now imagine how nice the doctors would be in a gov hospital to people with very little money.
Jammy, I don't understand you. If software guys can go to US and beg for Green cards, I don't see why doctors can't do the same thing. So, let's stop preaching what we don't practice. Like every professional, even doctors need money. The sad thing is that when a software monkey creates a product, it is assumed that there will be bugs. His imperfections are accepted. When it comes to a doc, we don't and it shouldn't be that way too. But come on, let's cut them some slack. Like there are sincere politicians, there are unprofessional doctors. That doesn't mean every doc is a bloodsucking vampire. I hope your family doc does not read your comment. Tell you what, if your company asks you to shift to USA or UK, what would you do? Say no in the name of patriotism? Give me a break dude.
Just a girl: I am sorry about your sister and I will not respond to your generalizations because I completely understand how you feel.
hey machi,
just letting you know if you can post an article on this on your website..
Jason Maude and Isabel Healtcare Ltd
A friend of mine told me about this about a month or two back and BBC has covered it recently in its news..
It would definitely help the doctors.
would appreciate that.
vasu
suman,
if u compare docs going to UK with SW profs going to USA then don't crib about the treatment u get in UK. U cribbed and whined and jammy responded to that. And ur response is just totally hillarious dude.
When a software "monkey" creates a buggy software no one dies. When a doc "gorilla" goofs up lives get shattered.
U give us a break from ur shitty comparisons.
Karthick you must be a software guy. Don't let me catch you in person. I might just fix your brain damage you f**k monkey. Dont you think before you write? Choooth!
hehe pissed_doc, u can't even know what a patient is suffering from unless u put his number on a software and read the notes, u gonna catch me. in ur dreams. Idiot. All that can come out of u is gaaliyan. thoo ek doctor ho kya.
Dear suman,
Fantastic Post man!! I just chanced upon this today and as a person embittered by the ordeal by fire i am elated that rational thinkers like you still exist in India!! Now that i have come through AIPGME 2006 singed but not burnt i hope and pray you continue to highlight the so called high and mighty doctors plight - Thanks Man.
I'll have to agree with Anusha when it comes to Malar hospital. My father was in coma for a month. We found some of the doctors attitudes disgusting!One of the doctors there is supposed to be one of those "super special good" ones. The way he spoke to us at times was shocking. Picture this- My dad's lying there and this doctor picks up his glasses and tells a junior doctor- "dei kick vennum na, indha soda budiya pottuko, beer vendaam". Another sample (this time directed towards me)- "Vonakkum inda maadiri high powera? Laser treatment panniko, kalyanam easya aagum"
The worst was that 2 sets of specialists had 2 different views on my father's prognosis. One said "prepare for the funeral" and the other "he's recovering". We went through hell for a month. On the day of my father's funeral, 2 guys turn up at our doorstep- "We are from malar hospital. The accounts section just found out that they hadn't billed correctly,please give us the balance right away". If this isn't inhuman then what is???? My stomach burns whenever I go past the hospital.
Good post man. Covered the issuse from all angles.
It was shocking to read whats in my mind published in web when i saw this site by chance...suman has told what's there in the mind of all those poor middle class souls who had opted for this noble profession...
About myself,i got thru both engineering and medical entrance exams in the first chance...got a seat in elec & tc in Govt eng collg n also a call from REC but opted for medicine .That is the worst decision i ever made in my life...
I studied in a govt med college where basic facilities where non existent which added to the tough curriculum...
by the time i was in final year,my 12th classmates who had opted for eng had alredy got jobs...it was painful as most of them went for eng after failing to get a MBBS seat..
by the time i finished my housejob,they had flewn to USA or B'lore with 5 or 6 digit salaries...
i spent next one year preparing for PG while my retired parents were still struggling with family budget...but the parents of my eng friends were planning which car to buy....
After 3 years of PG,here i am working for Rs 15000 in the govt sector under absymmal conditions 'serving the society' while my engineering friends are enjoying their life roaming around the world...
my fault? I choose medicine as my career.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home